A couple days ago I took the plunge and switch to Dvorak, but then I stumbled across a link to this site and now I'm switching again (honestly, I feel like my brain's about to explode). Dvorak is a brilliant design, but even after just two days I noticed a few little oddities. The "RL" problem, the awkward position of "F", the left-handed punctuation and the loss of the Edit menu cluster of "ZXCV", namely. I also had trouble with the separation of the vowels and consonants - I kept hitting the one next to the one I wanted in confusion because they were so densely packed...they actually work better when spaced out. Also, I must say that the Dvorak "the" made me happy, but yours fills me with glee - every other key right down the middle, and even left to right like the written word itself.
I did make a couple of slight changes, however. I swapped "J" and "B" because I feel that if any letter deserves to sit in the Dvorak "X" position, it certainly isn't "B". Better the unlovable "J" instead. Also, being a writer and not a coder, I left [ and ] in the corner and kept the Dvorak - and = alone so that I have easy access to the dash - my favourite little sentence separator and word-welder. The final change, however, I did just for myself. I swapped the question mark and the forward slash. Now all the punctuation (except !) is non-shifted and all the HTML markup is.
And yes, I typed this whole post (slowly) on Colemak, and it's certainly less painful than learning Dvorak (or perhaps I've so shocked my brain that I didn't notice...) - either way, thanks.
Maybe I can call my little remix Kolemak. Looks a bit clunky, but it still sounds as good.
-K