• You are not logged in.
  • Index
  • General
  • Hi, decided I'd best introduce myself...

    Hi, decided I'd best introduce myself...

    • Started by Darth Fluffy
    • 1 Replies:
    • Reputation: 0
    • Registered: 30-Apr-2006
    • Posts: 3

    ...since the board is such a small community. So hi everyone!

    Shai, I'm curious, if I don't care about qwerty compatability AND I strike zxc with ring-middle-index, would it be optimal for me to switch "c" and "f"?
    Also, same question but "b" and "v", the reach for b drives me bananas...
    Finally, if "g" is more comfortable than "p", should I switch these too? Maybe g is more freqeunt than p but because of how I hold my hands it is easier for me to hit "g"...
    Based on the above, should I go with ....

    QWCGP
    ARSTD
    ZXFBV

    Im fine with the right side, but my left hand goes against the angle of the keys...

    Offline
    • 0
    • Shai
    • Administrator
    • Reputation: 10
    • Registered: 11-Dec-2005
    • Posts: 385

    The recommended way to press Z-X-C-V-B is with the pinky-ring-middle-index-index, that way the hand is oriented so that hitting B isn't that difficult. Some keyboards such as the Kinesis contoured keyboard and the Datadesk SmartBoard keyboard align the keys in a more natural way, to avoid the long stretches of the 'B' position.

    There is some small benefit exchanging the 'B' (1.3%) and 'V' (0.9%) to reduce the frequency of hitting the 'B' position. However, I don't think that 0.4% difference is going to be very notable. Since the change would be rather confusing, and it will break comptability of the shortcut Ctrl+V and Ctrl+B, I really don't think it's worth it. Moreover, the combos AB/BA (stretch for both directions) are slightly less common than AV (in the word 'have').

    There is also some very small benefit exchanging 'C' and 'F', if you really don't like hitting the 'C' position, you can exchange 'C' and 'F'. I have left it there for compatibility reasons, but the improvement is very minor.

    I highly recommend leaving 'P' and 'G' in their places.  The 'pt'/'tp' combo is quite common (e.g. ftp, http, apt), and 'G' is usually followed by a letter on the other hand (e.g. 'gh'), so it's better to keep it there to avoid the hand stretching in two different directions.

    Even though you say you don't really care about compatibility, it's still a QWERTY world, and the similarity to QWERTY does help in the occasions that you are forced to use a QWERTY keyboard. Moreover, if you'll use a non-standard Colemak variant, you'll also have to adjust all the additional material, such as typing lessons, etc.

    Offline
    • 0
      • Index
      • General
      • Hi, decided I'd best introduce myself...