I'm afraid I don't really know how to analyze free-handed layouts. Just glancing, it doesn't look so bad to me. The numbers have to go somewhere (though I have to wonder whether the relative placements really reflect frequency), the vowels are mostly on one side. Some common letters are in weird out-of-way places (n) would be my main complaint, I guess due to lack of space. All in all, it does resemble a squished dvorak (aside from the vowels being on the opposite side).
Edit: a real complaint might be that he didn't take the opportunity to move any of the command keys (enter,backspace,shift,ctrl,alt,altgr) closer. To be fair, some would not have existed at the time. This could be a real area for improvement.
Last edited by lalop (31-Jul-2013 21:53:10)