Same-finger analysis for the two (punctuation, same-letter not analyzed):

Tarmak 1, in both cases, goes from QWERTY's 6.94% same-finger to 4.36%, a very respectable gain.

Tarmak (ETOIS):

```
Tarmak (ETOIS) 1:
digraphs Frequency Period
q,z 0.00% 3088227
a,q 0.00% 41722
a,z 0.04% 2719
w,x 0.00% 437621
s,w 0.06% 1706
s,x 0.00% 1221420
d,j 0.00% 20514
c,j 0.00% 439911
c,d 0.00% 21052
r,v 0.07% 1425
r,t 0.79% 127
f,r 0.25% 407
f,v 0.00% 1195982
f,t 0.09% 1145
f,g 0.00% 58273
t,v 0.00% 72322
g,r 0.30% 337
g,v 0.00% 679006
g,t 0.02% 5756
b,r 0.14% 723
b,f 0.00% 238156
b,v 0.00% 25430
b,t 0.02% 5089
b,g 0.00% 133329
h,y 0.05% 1976
h,k 0.00% 29247
h,u 0.07% 1338
h,n 0.04% 2729
h,m 0.01% 7532
k,y 0.01% 15925
k,u 0.01% 13107
k,n 0.10% 970
k,m 0.00% 51826
u,y 0.01% 16964
n,y 0.11% 900
n,u 0.47% 211
m,y 0.09% 1165
m,u 0.25% 395
m,n 0.04% 2737
e,i 0.57% 176
l,o 0.75% 133
Total 4.36% 23
Tarmak (ETOIS) 2:
digraphs Frequency Period
q,z 0.00% 3088227
a,q 0.00% 41722
a,z 0.04% 2719
w,x 0.00% 437621
s,w 0.06% 1706
s,x 0.00% 1221420
d,f 0.00% 30544
c,f 0.00% 50388
c,d 0.00% 21052
r,t 0.79% 127
r,v 0.07% 1425
t,v 0.00% 72322
g,r 0.30% 337
g,t 0.02% 5756
g,v 0.00% 679006
g,j 0.00% 1325074
j,r 0.00% 125628
j,t 0.00% 463188
j,v 0.00% 1153663
b,r 0.14% 723
b,t 0.02% 5089
b,v 0.00% 25430
b,g 0.00% 133329
b,j 0.02% 4292
h,y 0.05% 1976
h,k 0.00% 29247
h,u 0.07% 1338
h,n 0.04% 2729
h,m 0.01% 7532
k,y 0.01% 15925
k,u 0.01% 13107
k,n 0.10% 970
k,m 0.00% 51826
u,y 0.01% 16964
n,y 0.11% 900
n,u 0.47% 211
m,y 0.09% 1165
m,u 0.25% 395
m,n 0.04% 2737
e,i 0.57% 176
l,o 0.75% 133
Total 4.05% 25
Tarmak (ETOIS) 3:
digraphs Frequency Period
q,z 0.00% 3088227
a,q 0.00% 41722
a,z 0.04% 2719
w,x 0.00% 437621
s,w 0.06% 1706
s,x 0.00% 1221420
d,f 0.00% 30544
c,f 0.00% 50388
c,d 0.00% 21052
r,t 0.79% 127
r,v 0.07% 1425
t,v 0.00% 72322
g,r 0.30% 337
g,t 0.02% 5756
g,v 0.00% 679006
b,r 0.14% 723
b,t 0.02% 5089
b,v 0.00% 25430
b,g 0.00% 133329
j,k 0.00% 541068
j,u 0.06% 1689
j,n 0.01% 8902
j,m 0.00% 428334
h,j 0.00% 584478
h,k 0.00% 29247
h,u 0.07% 1338
h,n 0.04% 2729
h,m 0.01% 7532
k,u 0.01% 13107
k,n 0.10% 970
k,m 0.00% 51826
n,u 0.47% 211
m,u 0.25% 395
m,n 0.04% 2737
e,i 0.57% 176
l,y 0.44% 227
o,p 0.59% 171
Total 4.11% 24
Tarmak (ETOIS) 4:
digraphs Frequency Period
q,z 0.00% 3088227
a,q 0.00% 41722
a,z 0.04% 2719
w,x 0.00% 437621
s,w 0.06% 1706
s,x 0.00% 1221420
d,f 0.00% 30544
c,f 0.00% 50388
c,d 0.00% 21052
r,t 0.79% 127
r,v 0.07% 1425
t,v 0.00% 72322
g,r 0.30% 337
g,t 0.02% 5756
g,v 0.00% 679006
b,r 0.14% 723
b,t 0.02% 5089
b,v 0.00% 25430
b,g 0.00% 133329
j,k 0.00% 541068
j,l 0.00% 443193
j,n 0.01% 8902
j,m 0.00% 428334
h,j 0.00% 584478
h,k 0.00% 29247
h,l 0.01% 7037
h,n 0.04% 2729
h,m 0.01% 7532
k,l 0.03% 3302
k,n 0.10% 970
k,m 0.00% 51826
l,n 0.07% 1436
l,m 0.03% 3620
m,n 0.04% 2737
e,u 0.18% 560
i,y 0.03% 3443
o,p 0.59% 171
Total 2.59% 39
```

The main gains from Stage 4 to Stage 5 (Colemak) appear to be "rt"/"tr" (currently 0.79%), "op"/"po" (currently 0.59%), and "rg"/"gr" (currently 0.30%).

Tarmak (J-Hopper/ETSOI):

```
Tarmak (J-Hopper/ETSOI) 1:
digraphs Frequency Period
q,z 0.00% 3088227
a,q 0.00% 41722
a,z 0.04% 2719
w,x 0.00% 437621
s,w 0.06% 1706
s,x 0.00% 1221420
d,j 0.00% 20514
c,j 0.00% 439911
c,d 0.00% 21052
r,v 0.07% 1425
r,t 0.79% 127
f,r 0.25% 407
f,v 0.00% 1195982
f,t 0.09% 1145
f,g 0.00% 58273
t,v 0.00% 72322
g,r 0.30% 337
g,v 0.00% 679006
g,t 0.02% 5756
b,r 0.14% 723
b,f 0.00% 238156
b,v 0.00% 25430
b,t 0.02% 5089
b,g 0.00% 133329
h,y 0.05% 1976
h,k 0.00% 29247
h,u 0.07% 1338
h,n 0.04% 2729
h,m 0.01% 7532
k,y 0.01% 15925
k,u 0.01% 13107
k,n 0.10% 970
k,m 0.00% 51826
u,y 0.01% 16964
n,y 0.11% 900
n,u 0.47% 211
m,y 0.09% 1165
m,u 0.25% 395
m,n 0.04% 2737
e,i 0.57% 176
l,o 0.75% 133
Total 4.36% 23
Tarmak (J-Hopper/ETSOI) 2:
digraphs Frequency Period
q,z 0.00% 3088227
a,q 0.00% 41722
a,z 0.04% 2719
w,x 0.00% 437621
s,w 0.06% 1706
s,x 0.00% 1221420
d,f 0.00% 30544
c,f 0.00% 50388
c,d 0.00% 21052
r,t 0.79% 127
r,v 0.07% 1425
t,v 0.00% 72322
g,r 0.30% 337
g,t 0.02% 5756
g,v 0.00% 679006
g,j 0.00% 1325074
j,r 0.00% 125628
j,t 0.00% 463188
j,v 0.00% 1153663
b,r 0.14% 723
b,t 0.02% 5089
b,v 0.00% 25430
b,g 0.00% 133329
b,j 0.02% 4292
h,y 0.05% 1976
h,k 0.00% 29247
h,u 0.07% 1338
h,n 0.04% 2729
h,m 0.01% 7532
k,y 0.01% 15925
k,u 0.01% 13107
k,n 0.10% 970
k,m 0.00% 51826
u,y 0.01% 16964
n,y 0.11% 900
n,u 0.47% 211
m,y 0.09% 1165
m,u 0.25% 395
m,n 0.04% 2737
e,i 0.57% 176
l,o 0.75% 133
Total 4.05% 25
Tarmak (J-Hopper/ETSOI) 3:
digraphs Frequency Period
q,z 0.00% 3088227
a,q 0.00% 41722
a,z 0.04% 2719
w,x 0.00% 437621
r,w 0.04% 2298
r,x 0.00% 83181
f,s 0.02% 4410
c,f 0.00% 50388
c,s 0.18% 563
j,t 0.00% 463188
j,v 0.00% 1153663
t,v 0.00% 72322
g,j 0.00% 1325074
g,t 0.02% 5756
g,v 0.00% 679006
d,j 0.00% 20514
d,t 0.00% 23857
d,v 0.02% 5168
d,g 0.03% 2927
b,j 0.02% 4292
b,t 0.02% 5089
b,v 0.00% 25430
b,g 0.00% 133329
b,d 0.01% 19058
h,y 0.05% 1976
h,k 0.00% 29247
h,u 0.07% 1338
h,n 0.04% 2729
h,m 0.01% 7532
k,y 0.01% 15925
k,u 0.01% 13107
k,n 0.10% 970
k,m 0.00% 51826
u,y 0.01% 16964
n,y 0.11% 900
n,u 0.47% 211
m,y 0.09% 1165
m,u 0.25% 395
m,n 0.04% 2737
e,i 0.57% 176
l,o 0.75% 133
Total 3.00% 33
Tarmak (J-Hopper/ETSOI) 4:
digraphs Frequency Period
q,z 0.00% 3088227
a,q 0.00% 41722
a,z 0.04% 2719
w,x 0.00% 437621
r,w 0.04% 2298
r,x 0.00% 83181
f,s 0.02% 4410
c,f 0.00% 50388
c,s 0.18% 563
p,t 0.11% 908
p,v 0.00% 240337
t,v 0.00% 72322
g,p 0.00% 112932
g,t 0.02% 5756
g,v 0.00% 679006
d,p 0.00% 34114
d,t 0.00% 23857
d,v 0.02% 5168
d,g 0.03% 2927
b,p 0.00% 53884
b,t 0.02% 5089
b,v 0.00% 25430
b,g 0.00% 133329
b,d 0.01% 19058
j,k 0.00% 541068
j,u 0.06% 1689
j,n 0.01% 8902
j,m 0.00% 428334
h,j 0.00% 584478
h,k 0.00% 29247
h,u 0.07% 1338
h,n 0.04% 2729
h,m 0.01% 7532
k,u 0.01% 13107
k,n 0.10% 970
k,m 0.00% 51826
n,u 0.47% 211
m,u 0.25% 395
m,n 0.04% 2737
e,i 0.57% 176
l,y 0.44% 227
Total 2.59% 39
```

The stage 4 total is quite a coincidence.

It's amazing how much is gained from swapping LUI. The main gains are "ei"/"ie" (currently 0.57%), "nu"/"un" (currently 0.47%), and "ly"/"yl" (currently 0.44%).

In both cases, the gain from Stage 4 to 5 is 1.52%, down to Colemak's 1.07% same-finger.

Last edited by lalop (15-Apr-2014 10:33:21)